The Tragic Disaster of American Airlines Flight 191 and the Chain of Failures That Led to the Deadliest U.S. Aviation Catastrophe

   

America's Worst Accident | Plane Crashes After TakeOff in Chicago |  American Airlines 191 | 4K

On May 25, 1979, American Airlines Flight 191, a McDonnell Douglas DC-10, was scheduled for a routine flight from Chicago’s O'Hare International Airport to Los Angeles International Airport. 

The flight was carrying 271 people—258 passengers and 13 crew members—on what should have been a typical, five-hour journey.

Instead, it would become one of the most devastating events in aviation history, as an unimaginable series of failures led to the deadliest aircraft crash on U.S. soil at the time.

What began as a normal departure soon turned into a catastrophic disaster that would leave the world in shock and forever alter the way aviation safety is approached.

The aircraft in question, a McDonnell Douglas DC-10, had been in service for several years and was part of American Airlines' efforts to increase the capacity on its long-haul routes.

Despite a long and storied career in the skies, the DC-10 had already been linked to several incidents, including a major issue during a test flight in 1972 that involved the failure of the cargo door.

Unfortunately, this would not be the last tragedy involving the DC-10. For Flight 191, a small defect would set off a chain reaction that ultimately led to its tragic end.

 

American Airlines Flight 191 - A Cabin Crew Perspective

At 3:04 p.m., after receiving takeoff clearance, Flight 191 began its taxi along Runway 32R at O'Hare, accelerating rapidly.

As the aircraft reached takeoff speed, the pilots were met with an unexpected jolt. A loud bang echoed from the left side of the aircraft, and immediately the left wing began to tilt down.

Something was terribly wrong. Within seconds, the crew learned that engine number one had detached from the wing entirely. The engine, along with its attached pylon, had broken off and slammed into the runway below.

The separation of the engine caused immediate, catastrophic damage to the plane’s electrical and hydraulic systems, leaving the crew with limited control over the aircraft.

As the plane veered to the left and continued to climb, the pilots, Captain Walter Lux and First Officer James Dillard, struggled to maintain control.

Despite their extensive experience, including a combined 40,000 hours of flight time, they were facing a scenario that no amount of training could have fully prepared them for.

As the engine tore away from the wing, it also severed key hydraulic lines, effectively disabling critical flight control systems.

The aircraft’s speed brakes, wing flaps, and ailerons were rendered inoperable, leaving the pilots with a severely compromised ability to control the aircraft. 

Flight 191 crash, 40 years later

As the situation grew more dire, the cockpit crew attempted to assess the situation and navigate through the growing panic in the cabin. With both fuel and hydraulic lines ruptured, the aircraft was quickly becoming an unmanageable danger.

Within moments of the engine’s detachment, the pilots tried to declare an emergency, but their efforts were in vain. The aircraft continued its uneven flight, losing stability and experiencing further control issues.

The crew knew that landing the aircraft was the only viable option, but without control over key systems, they faced the near-impossible task of guiding the crippled plane back to safety.

To make matters worse, the plane’s ability to carry out an emergency landing was severely compromised, and every moment spent in the air increased the risk of a catastrophic failure.

As the aircraft passed through an altitude of about 3,000 feet, it became evident that the pilots were not going to make it back to the airport in time.

The cabin crew, who had already seen the damage to the left wing and observed the growing fuel leak, began to panic. The fear of a massive explosion or crash grew stronger as the aircraft veered off course.

Despite the perilous situation, the crew’s quick thinking allowed them to relay vital information to air traffic control, who began to prepare for a possible emergency landing.

Vintage Chicago Tribune: Plane crashes that stunned our city – Chicago  Tribune

Meanwhile, on the ground, the news about the engine separation and fuel leak was spreading quickly. Passengers in the cabin began to realize the severity of the situation.

Some of the most alarming images from this incident came from the onboard cameras, where passengers saw the large streaks of fuel pouring out from the wing.

The visible damage to the aircraft only heightened the fears of those on board, as they braced themselves for an uncertain outcome.

After spending several minutes troubleshooting the emergency, the pilots realized that an immediate landing was not feasible. They needed more time to stabilize the aircraft and evaluate the damage before attempting the critical landing.

Meanwhile, on the ground, emergency crews prepared for the worst, positioning firefighting equipment and clearing areas to prevent casualties if the plane failed to land safely.

Ultimately, the decision was made to bring the aircraft down. However, with the compromised wing, loss of hydraulic control, and severely damaged systems, the landing would be anything but ordinary.

The pilots were forced to make a final approach to the runway, managing what little control they had left. The aircraft was incredibly heavy due to the fuel loss, and the damaged control surfaces made the descent a delicate maneuver. After several tense moments, the plane made a final, crash-landing attempt on runway 32R.

Remembering Flight 191 – Hartford Courant

The landing was far from smooth. The aircraft had no functioning speed brakes, and only one of its engines was functioning in reverse to slow it down. As the plane slid across the runway, emergency vehicles and firefighting teams rushed to the scene.

Unfortunately, the aircraft was unable to stop in time. The fire that erupted from the wreckage was massive, and the explosion that followed was heard from miles away.

Emergency responders were quick to arrive, but the devastation had already taken its toll. Despite the heroic efforts of the crew, the crash claimed the lives of all 271 people on board, along with several individuals working at the hangar where the plane crashed.

The aftermath of the crash prompted a thorough investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB).

While it was clear that the engine failure had caused the accident, the investigation delved deeper into how the engine detached from the aircraft and why the crew was unable to land the plane safely. 

It was eventually determined that the cause of the engine detachment was a failure to follow standard maintenance procedures during routine servicing of the aircraft.

44 năm kể từ chuyến bay 191 của American Airlines : r/aircrashinvestigation

This maintenance mistake led to a catastrophic failure that was directly responsible for the crash.

In the years following the incident, the aviation industry took steps to ensure that such a disaster would never happen again. Major changes were made to the way aircraft maintenance was handled, particularly concerning the DC-10 aircraft, which had become a symbol of aviation safety failures.

The FAA also implemented stricter maintenance protocols, and all airlines were required to adopt enhanced safety measures to ensure the integrity of their fleets.

The tragedy of Flight 191 remains one of the most heartbreaking moments in aviation history. While improvements in aircraft safety and maintenance have been made, the lives lost in that crash remind us of the importance of diligence and caution in aviation.

The crew of Flight 191, despite facing overwhelming odds, did everything in their power to save their passengers, and their bravery serves as a testament to the courage and professionalism that all pilots strive to uphold.

As we reflect on the legacy of Flight 191, we must continue to prioritize safety, transparency, and rigorous standards in the aviation industry. The lessons learned from that day continue to shape the future of flight, ensuring that the lives of those lost will not be in vain.