Zohran Mamdani Silent as Trump Brands Him Communist Threat to New York City

In a political confrontation that could reshape the future of New York City, Democratic mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani finds himself at the center of a firestorm after President Donald Trump and his allies unleashed blistering attacks, labeling him a "100% Communist Lunatic."

The escalating controversy reached new heights on Friday when Mamdani, confronted by Fox News Digital outside his Queens apartment, laughed off direct questions about his alleged communist affiliations and refused to offer any substantive response to the accusations being hurled at him from both sides of the political spectrum.

The sharp rebuke from the former president comes as New York's mayoral race intensifies between Mamdani, incumbent Mayor Eric Adams, former Governor Andrew Cuomo, and Republican challenger Curtis Sliwa.

While Mamdani has built a reputation among progressives for his unapologetic leftist views, his critics argue that his policy positions and public statements unmistakably echo the doctrines of Karl Marx, prompting fears that New York City could be pushed further into ideological extremes if he assumes office.

Fox News Digital reporters approached Mamdani on Friday morning, pressing him directly on the accusations that he is a communist and on whether he plans to moderate his political rhetoric ahead of a scheduled meeting with House Democratic Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries.

“Do you have any response to those who label you a communist?” a reporter asked. “Do you plan on walking back any statements when you meet with Leader Jeffries, like seizing the means of production?”

Rather than offering clarifications or defenses, Mamdani merely chuckled and refused to answer, leaving the public to interpret his silence. The moment was caught on camera and quickly circulated online, amplifying concerns among critics and energizing his opponents.

President Trump wasted no time seizing on the episode, unleashing a scathing post on Truth Social that not only denounced Mamdani but ridiculed the Democratic Party as having finally abandoned all pretense of moderation.

“It’s finally happened, the Democrats have crossed the line,” Trump wrote. “Zohran Mamdani, a 100% Communist Lunatic, has just won the Dem Primary, and is on his way to becoming Mayor. We’ve had Radical Lefties before, but this is getting a little ridiculous.”

In characteristic Trump fashion, the former president did not stop there. He took aim at Mamdani’s appearance, intelligence, and political backers. “He looks TERRIBLE, his voice is grating, he’s not very smart, he’s got AOC+3, Dummies ALL, backing him, and even our Great Palestinian Senator, Cryin’ Chuck Schumer, is groveling over him. Yes, this is a big moment in the History of our Country!”

Trump’s son, Donald Trump Jr., echoed his father’s concerns in a separate interview with Fox News Digital. He framed Mamdani’s potential victory as a grim milestone for New York City but a possible turning point for the country.

“If this communist mayor gets elected, rock bottom is what New York's going to see,” Trump Jr. warned. “Sometimes you have to hit rock bottom, and perhaps this is exactly what America needs to wake up. It could be the greatest marketing campaign for Florida yet.”

The Trumps’ harsh rhetoric follows weeks of growing anxiety within New York’s political establishment, particularly after Mamdani secured the Democratic mayoral nomination in a stunning upset that blindsided moderates.

His rise has been fueled by endorsements from progressive icons like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Democratic Socialists of America, as well as grassroots support from left-wing activists eager to radically transform the city’s governance.

Yet Mamdani’s own words from the past have come back to haunt him. Mayor Eric Adams, himself under fire for various controversies during his term, resurfaced a 2020 tweet from Mamdani quoting Karl Marx: “Each according to their need, each according to their ability.”

Adams, once a Democrat but increasingly distancing himself from his party’s left wing, used the opportunity to label Mamdani a Marxist in everything but name.

Adding fuel to the fire, a video clip from a previous interview has recirculated online, showing Mamdani musing about the abolition of private property in the context of solving the housing crisis.

“My platform is that every single person should have housing,” Mamdani stated. “If there was any system that could guarantee each person housing, whether you call it the abolition of private property or just a statewide housing guarantee, it is preferable to what is going on right now.”

These remarks have drawn sharp criticism from Republican figures like Rep. Nicole Malliotakis of New York, who bluntly stated, “He claims to be a socialist, whether it's wanting to abolish private property or wanting to seize the means of production, these are communist ideas right out of the playbook of Karl Marx.”

Mamdani’s scheduled meeting with House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries was already drawing scrutiny even before his Friday encounter with Fox News Digital.

Jeffries, a Brooklyn native and prominent figure in the national Democratic Party, faces mounting pressure to publicly address the ideological rift within his party, especially as Mamdani’s rise symbolizes the growing influence of the Democratic Socialists within urban politics.

Meanwhile, former Governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican candidate Curtis Sliwa have seized on the controversy to position themselves as bulwarks against the city’s potential leftward lurch.

Cuomo, attempting a political comeback after his resignation, has framed himself as a pragmatic centrist capable of rescuing the city from what he calls “the ideological extremism threatening to tear it apart.”

Sliwa, founder of the Guardian Angels and a vocal Trump ally, has made combating socialism in New York his central campaign theme, describing Mamdani’s policies as “a death sentence for the middle class.”

Despite the growing chorus of criticism, Mamdani has remained defiant in his public appearances, portraying the attacks against him as evidence of his disruptive potential.

In recent campaign rallies, he has sidestepped direct engagement with the communist label, instead focusing on issues like universal housing, environmental justice, and dismantling systemic inequality.

His supporters argue that the red scare tactics deployed by opponents are designed to distract from the real crises facing New Yorkers, including homelessness, gentrification, and police reform.

Yet, Mamdani’s refusal to provide straightforward answers when pressed has left even some of his sympathizers uneasy. For a candidate positioning himself as a transparent advocate for the people, his silence in the face of legitimate inquiries has raised questions about what he might actually implement if elected.

Political analysts suggest that Mamdani’s strategy might be calculated—by not directly addressing the communist label, he avoids getting bogged down in ideological debates that could alienate moderate voters. But this approach carries risks, particularly if opponents successfully frame him as evasive or untrustworthy.

New York City, a metropolis of complexity and contradictions, now stands at a political crossroads. The mayoral race has evolved into more than just a contest over policies—it is a referendum on the city’s identity, values, and future direction.

With Trump’s thunderous commentary echoing across conservative media, Mamdani's candidacy is no longer just a local story; it has become a national spectacle.

As Election Day approaches, the stakes could not be higher. Will New Yorkers embrace Mamdani’s vision of democratic socialism, despite—or perhaps because of—the relentless communist accusations? Or will the mounting backlash crystallized by Trump’s denunciation sway the electorate back toward the political center or right?

What remains clear is that Zohran Mamdani’s silence when directly confronted only intensifies the scrutiny. And in a city as politically charged as New York, silence can sometimes speak louder than any words.

Full video: